Dough, it’s buttery, crusty, golden, and delicious. I think I actually eat pies and other pastries most of the time just to eat the dough itself. You would think that I would have known how to make my own golden pastry dough, but up until last weekend I had never really tried it. Ever since I got my food processor (which seems to be a common sentence intro) I have been wanting to take advantage of its magical powers, cue the pastry dough!
One of my very dear friend’s Caitlin came to visit me last weekend and I wanted to prepare something special for her for dinner. I had been watching an episode of Giada at Home on the Food Network and really enjoyed her episode on making cheese the main star in your dish. So, I set out to prepare what I thought was a savory Crostata as an accompaniment to our meal. The dish included apples (in season), gorgonzola cheese (yum) and walnuts (in my pantry) so it sounded like a great idea. Plus, it gave me the long awaited opportunity to make pastry dough.

Quick aside: Does anyone else ever do what I do, make a dish for the first time for a guest as opposed to making a classic you know how to make?? I never mean to do this, but it always seems to work out that way. Thankfully I have wonderful friends who like to try my experiments
So back to the dough…I could have gone with Giada’s recipe, but it called for mascarpone cheese, and quite honestly, I didn’t feel like going out to buy it. So, I researched my no-fail foodie goddess Ina Garten and tried my hand at the Barefoot Contessa’s pastry dough. The best thing about making pastry dough is that 1) it requires minimal ingredients you should always have one hand, and 2) it takes almost no time to prepare.
Ingredients as follows:
1 cup all-purpose flour
2 tablespoons granulated sugar or superfine sugar
1/4 teaspoon kosher salt
1/4 lb very cold unsalted butter, diced
2 tablespoons ice water
Using the steel mixing blade in your food processor, pour in the flour, sugar, and salt, and pulse 2-3 times until all the ingredients are nice and incorporated. Next, add the diced butter and pulse again 12-15 times until the butter is mixed in with the flour mixture and is the size of peas, and looks like course sand. NOTE: Make sure your butter is VERY cold for the best results. Helpful trick is to place the stick in the freezer 5-10 minutes before you are ready to use it. Try using it with room temperature butter and you will not be very happy with your finished product.
Next, with the feed tube removed from the lid of your food processor, pour in the ice water while pulsing to combine, about 4-5 times, or until just before the dough turns into a solid mass.
Lastly, flour a cutting board or other firm surface and scoop out your dough mixture. Using your hands, mold the mixture together into a disk, about 2-3 inches thick (see photo). Place the dough in plastic wrap and refrigerate for at least one hour, or, if you want to freeze for later, straight into the freezer where it will last for up to 3 months. If you are planning on freezing it, I suggest wrapping it in an additional layer of wax paper.
Guess what? You just made homemade pastry dough! Now all that’s left to do is decide what to make with it. This dough is great for pies, crostatas, tortes, or anything else you want to wrap in a buttery shell of deliciousness. Which brings me back to my story about the Apple Gorgonzola Crostata…
Thinking this would be a savory dish because of the gorgonzola cheese, I went ahead and prepared it well before dinner leaving me enough time to try it and make sure it wasn’t awful. As soon as I got the apples in the pan with the butter and sugar, I quickly realized this wasn’t going to be anywhere near savory. I thought once I add the gorgonzola it will smooth it out, but unfortunately, while the mixture tasted delicious, it tasted like dessert. Not that this stopped me from continuing on with my dish, but I went to plan b for the side dish.
When all was said and done, this made a great dessert. The goronzola cheese brought an interesting flavor combination to the sweetness of the apples, but in a good way. Perhaps next time around I would use slightly less gorgonzola than the recipe calls for, but thats all a matter of personal preference, after all it is a strong cheese.
Storage tip: Do NOT leave this sitting on your counter for longer than an hour or so after it’s done baking, place right into the refrigerator. I made this mistake and wound up with a mushy smelly mess the next morning that I wasn’t able to finish eating
Lesson learned!
Moral of the story: Give pastry dough a try! If you haven’t already, use this recipe to make some yummy pies and treats for the upcoming holiday season. It is fresher and cheaper than a store bought dough and you will have a wonderful sense of satisfaction when you tell your friends that you made the crust yourself!
Click here for the recipe for the Apple & Gorgonzola Crostata





Tara O'Keeffe